Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a manifestation of hyperactivated lymphocytes and results, in part, from the loss of normal tolerance checkpoints. FOXO1 is a transcription factor involved at critical early and late B cell development checkpoints; however, its role in regulating peripheral B cell tolerance is not fully understood. We have applied our published approach for using imaging flow cytometry to study native FOXO1 localisation in human lymphocytes to peripheral blood samples from healthy individuals versus patients with SLE. We report, here, on dramatic cytoplasmic localisation of FOXO1 in two peripheral B cell SLE subsets: IgD-CD27+ (class-switched memory) B cells and IgD-CD27- (atypical memory) B cells. The latter, so-called ‘Double Negative’ (DN) B cells have previously been shown to be increased in SLE and enriched in autoreactive clones. Cytoplasmic-predominant FOXO1 (CytoFOX) B cells are significantly increased in patients with SLE as compared to healthy controls, and the levels of CytoFoOX DN B cells correlate directly with SLE disease activity. The highest abundance of CytoFox DN B cells was observed in African American females with SLE Disease Activity Index (SLEDAI)≥6. The phenotype of CytoFOX DN B cells in SLE includes uniquely low CD20 expression and high granularity/side scatter. As FOXO1 phosphorylation downstream of B cell receptor-dependent signalling is required for nuclear exclusion, CytoFOX B cells likely represent a high state of B cell activation with excess signalling and/or loss of phosphatase activity. We hypothesise that CytoFOX B cells in lupus represent a novel biomarker for the expansion of pathological, autoreactive B cells which may provide new insights into the pathophysiology of SLE.
- systemic lupus erythematosus
- b cell
- disease activity
This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, appropriate credit is given, any changes made indicated, and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a manifestation of hyperactivated lymphocytes and results, in part, from the loss of normal tolerance checkpoints.1–3 FOXO1 is a transcription factor involved at critical early and late B cell development checkpoints; however, its role in regulating peripheral B cell tolerance is not fully understood. We have applied our published approach for using imaging flow cytometry (IFC)4 to study native FOXO1 localisation in human lymphocytes to peripheral blood samples from healthy individuals versus patients with SLE. We report, here, on dramatic cytoplasmic localisation of FOXO1 in two peripheral B cell SLE subsets: IgD-CD27+ (switched memory) B cells and IgD-CD27- (atypical memory) B cells. Cytoplasmic-predominant FOXO1 (CytoFOX) B cells are significantly increased in patients with SLE as compared with healthy controls, and the levels of CytoFOX double negative (DN) B cells correlate directly with SLE disease activity. CytoFOX B cells likely represent a high state of B cell activation. We hypothesise that CytoFOX B cells in lupus represent a novel biomarker for the expansion of pathological, autoreactive B cells which may provide new insights into the pathophysiology of SLE.
Imaging flow cytometry (IFC) reliably and quantitatively assesses changes in FOXO1 localisation in subpopulations of primary human B cells
At baseline, total B cells and B cell subsets have predominantly nuclear FOXO1 (figure 1A,C and online supplementary figure 1). After BCR stimulation with αIg F(ab’)2, FOXO1 moves to the cytoplasm in all B cell subsets (figure 1B), shown by the significant decreases in FOXO1 mean similarity (figure 1C,D and data not shown) at the 30 and 60 min time points. These findings are consistent with studies indicating that cytoplasmic FOXO1 localisation accompanies B cell activation due to PI3K/AKT signalling downstream of the BCR.5 6 We conclude that IFC is a reliable and reproducible method for detecting dynamic changes in native FOXO1 localisation within user-defined subsets of peripheral human B cells.
DN and switched memory B cells from patients with SLE have significantly more cytoplasmic FOXO1 compared to healthy donors
We compared four subsets of peripheral B cells in patients with SLE and healthy donors: naïve (IgD +CD27-), DN atypical-memory (IgD-CD27-), switched-memory (IgD-CD27+) and unswitched-memory (IgD+CD27+) (online supplementary table 1). In healthy donors, all peripheral B cells had nuclear FOXO1 (figure 1A). In patients with SLE, however, DN B cells had a significantly lower mean similarity of FOXO1 and DAPI compared with healthy volunteers (p<0.0001) indicating that FOXO1 is predominantly cytoplasmic in DN B cells of many patients with SLE (CytoFOX) (figure 2A,E). Patients with SLE also have significantly more CytoFOX DN B cells than healthy controls (~80% vs ~25%) (p<0.0001) (figure 2F). Switched-memory and to a lesser extent naïve B cells, but not unswitched-memory cells also displayed a statistically significant increase in cytoplasmic FOXO1 (figure 2B,C,D,F).
Patients with SLE have higher percent DN B cells compared to healthy donors and CytoFOX DN B cells correlate with disease activity
When comparing the percentages of each B cell subset as part of a total typical human B cell compartment, we found a number of variations in the B cell subsets in patients with SLE. As in previous studies,7 8 we found that patients with SLE have a higher percentage of the DN B cell population compared with healthy donors (p=0.0006) (figure 3A), and a significantly decreased percentage of unswitched-memory B cells (p=0.001) (online supplementary figure 2) and switched-memory B cells (p=0.03) (online supplementary figure 2).7 8 Total and naïve B cell percentages did not significantly differ between patients with SLE and healthy donors (online supplementary figure 2). The per cent DN B cells in patients with SLE did not correlate with SLEDAI (online supplementary figure 3), also consistent with previous work.7 However, we did find a strong positive correlation between per cent CytoFOX DN B cells and disease activity in patients with SLE (figure 3B).
CytoFOX DN B cells from patients with SLE have lower CD20 and increased granularity
We examined a number of phenotypic markers to further characterise the CytoFOX population of DN B cells in patients with SLE and healthy donors. CD20 is expressed on all mature B cells and pre-B cells, but is downregulated in plasma cells.9 Mean intensity of CD20 expression was determined in IDEAS (V.6.2) for the B cells in each of the four subsets analysed above. IgD-CD27- DN B cells had a significantly lower CD20 intensity in patients with SLE compared with healthy controls, in particular CytoFOX DN B cells (p=0.0191) (figure 3C). CD20 intensity did not significantly differ between patients with SLE and healthy donors in naïve, switched-memory or unswitched-memory B cells, independent of FOXO1 localisation (online supplementary figure 4). Within patients with SLE, CytoFOX DN B cells had significantly decreased CD20 expression when compared with nuclFOX DN B cells (p=0.0353) (online supplementary figure 4); however, they do not stain positive for plasma cell marker CD38 (data not shown).
In flow cytometric analysis, activated B cells and plasmablasts have higher Side Scatter (SSC), indicating increased granularity.10 Thus, we assessed SSC in the DN B cells of the patients with SLE and healthy donors. Cells were gated based on higher or lower SSC in the total CD19+ CD20+ population (intensity and visual inspection confirmed, data not shown). These gates were applied to DN B cells (online supplementary figure 4). Based on these findings, we designed an IFC gating strategy based on CD20 and SSC intensity that allowed us to confidently gate on a population of cells with ~80%–90% CytoFOX (figure 3D). Additionally, the percentage of SSChi/CD20lo within the DN B cell compartment positively correlated with disease activity in patients with active SLE (SLEDAI ≥4) (r=0.6245) (p=0.0151) (figure 3E). By gating on SSChi/CD20lo B cells that are also IgD-/CD27-, we are able to reliably identify the CytoFOX DN B cells, which will allow us to live-sort these cells for future studies.
The CytoFOX DN B cells in SLE had increased granularity, which is sometimes used as a measure of activation.10 However, in order to more definitely assess the activation state of these CytoFOX DN B cells, SLE (n=6) and HC (n=10) samples were also surface stained with CD95, a classic activation maker, also known as Fas. CD95 is upregulated on active cells and has been shown to be increased on B cells in SLE, including DN B cells.11 Additionally, the percentage of CD95+ DN B cells correlates with disease activity in patients with SLE.12 We confirmed that both SLE and healthy donors (online supplementary figure 5) have CD95+ DN B cells. CD95+ DN B cells have more cytoplasmic FOXO1 than CD95- DN B cells in patients with SLE while both CD95+ and CD95- DN B cells from healthy donors have predominantly nuclear FOXO1 (online supplementary figure 5D,E).
We also categorised patients based on two of the SLE symptoms associated with poorer outcomes and more active, inflammatory disease--nephritis and presence of double stranded DNA autoantibodies (dsDNA autoAb). Only patients with greater than 58% CytoFOX DN B cells had nephritis (n=8), positive dsDNA autoAbs (n=5) or both (n=4) as compared with those with <58% CytoFOX DN B cells (figure 3F). χ² analysis (data not shown) showed a significant association between frequency of CytoFOX DN B cells and severe SLE disease manifestations.
We found that the percentage of CytoFOX DN B cells was positively associated with disease activity in patients with SLE. Furthermore, patients above a certain level of CytoFOX DN B cells were much more likely to have manifestations of more severe disease, including positive anti-dsDNA autoAbs and nephritis.13 14 Our discovery of increased CytoFOX in DN B cells provides a new biomarker for increased risk of active SLE disease.
By gating on high SSChi/CD20lo cells, we were able to identify a population of DN B cells that were 80%–90% CytoFOX. This gating strategy will allow us to live-sort these cells for further ex vivo experiments, including B cell effector function, stimulation of antibody secretion combined with EliSpot to determine antigen specificity, and BCR sequencing to determine potential clonal relationships of the DN B cells subsets to other B cells subsets.
Since CytoFOX DN B cells have lower CD20, higher SSC and higher CD95 expression, this suggests that they are more activated than other B cell subsets. Both BCR and BAFFR signalling have been linked, via PI3K/AKT activation, to phosphorylation and nuclear exclusion of FOXO1.15 Taken together, our findings suggest that the cytoplasmic localisation of FOXO1 in SLE DN B cells is linked to B cell hyperactivation.
In summary, we have identified a subset of IgD-CD27- (DN) atypical memory B cells with CytoFOX, higher SSC and lower CD20 that are significantly increased in patients with SLE with higher disease activity. These cells bear the hallmarks of excessive activation and it is likely that the cytoplasmic FOXO1 reflects this increased activation. Additionally, CytoFOX DN B cells potentially represent a pool of memory cells that can respond to intracellular autoantigens like RNA and DNA and potentiate the smouldering immune activity that characterises SLE. Future experiments will focus on further characterising the origin and antigen-specificity of these CytoFOX DN B cells and the mechanisms that maintain these unusual cells in the periphery in the setting of SLE inflammation.
AG would like to acknowledge his completed VA funding including VA grant IK2 CX000649-01A1 as well as VA SHEEP grant IS1 BX003571-01. The authors would like to acknowledge the assistance of Dr Martin Flajnik for helpful comments on the manuscript.
Contributors MKHA designed and performed the experiments, analysed the data, prepared the figures and helped to edit the manuscript. AG designed the experiments, analysed the data, prepared the figures and wrote the manuscript. AG designed the experiments, analysed the data, prepared the figures and wrote the manuscript.
Funding AG wishes to acknowledge his completed VA CDA-2 award support—VA grant IK2 CX000649-01A1. Additionally, MKHA and AG would like to acknowledge the VA SHEEP grant IS1 BX003571-01 that provided funding for acquisition of the Amnis Imagestream Mark II imaging flow cytometer at the Baltimore VA Research Core.
Disclaimer The contents do not represent the views of the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs or the United States Government.
Competing interests None declared.
Patient consent Not required.
Ethics approval This study involved human subjects. Approval for this study was obtained from the University of Maryland School of Medicine IRB as well as the Baltimore VA Research Office of Human Research Protection. There is no identifiable medical information in this manuscript. All patient identities have been removed. Per our IRB-approved protocol, all participants signed informed consent. All identifiable information has been removed from the reported data.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Data sharing statement There are no unpublished data from the study as we have included all the data either in the main document or in the supplemental information. Also, our previously published manuscript in Journal of Immunological Methods (Hritzo et al, 2018) provides very detailed information on how to use the AMNIS ImageStream to visualise FOXO1 in human lymphocytes.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.